Combined effect of nano-silica and silica fume to improve concrete workability and compressive strength: a case study and an overview of the literature.

Abstract

Several types of amorphous silica generate pozzolanic reactions at micro- and nano-scale, which can improve concrete macro-structural characteristic. However, their addition can raise the viscosity of the mixture, thus decreasing its workability. In the present work is proposed an experimental setup to determine concrete compression and manageability performance adding Silica Fume (SF), 0.0, 6.5, 8.5, 10.0% w/b, colloidal silica (nSi), 0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5% w/b and SF-nSi combined, 0.0-0.0, 0.2-8.5, 0.2-10% w/b, and an extensive overview of the literature for concrete mixtures with SF, nSi and SF-nSi combined. The results show that the addition of SF can increase compressive strength by 12%, nevertheless, can also lead to decreases in manageability of the sample (e.g., a decrease by 67% for a dosage of 10.0% w/b). On the other hand, nSi can increase compressive strength by up to 25% with a dosage of 2.5% and can increase the manageability by 78% for dosages greater than 0.5% w/b. When combining the two materials, an increase in compressive strength was observed, along with a loss of workability. A statistical analysis of the data found in literature is proposed, highlighting interesting trends of behavior between SF and nSi with workability and compressive strength, as well as a lack of research for slump outcomes and for the effects of combined additives in concrete. Finally, a short cost-benefit analysis of the mixtures is proposed.